National Writing Project

The Emerging Shape of Voice

By: Sherry Swain, Richard L. Graves, David Morse
Publication: English Journal
Date: May 2015

Summary: This article details research exploring which rhetorical elements are associated with statewide assessment scores and considers the role and occurrence of voice in student writing to inform teaching practice.

 

Voice grows out of the rich soil of student writing, not from drills or lectures or admonitions, not from workbooks or textbooks. Voice emerges in the course of the composing process, a by-product of the writer's focus on content, purpose, diction, style, and audience. The key word is emerge. The creation of voice is not an end in itself but a by-product growing out of the process of writing. Preoccupation with voice shifts the point of view from 'you' to 'I,' from focus on audience to focus on self. Rhetorical features themselves are not voice. Voice is observed indirectly or intuitively through the rhetorical features. Since voice is observed indirectly, it follows then that the major teaching of voice should also be indirect.

Definitions of voice, plentiful as they are, do not give us clues about how to teach it. In the past, we've heard ourselves say, 'Write like you talk'; or 'Let the reader hear your voice.' But now Common Core State Standards (CCSS) demand that students 'establish and maintain formal style' for informational and argumentative writing and 'style appropriate to task, purpose, and audience' for narrative writing (44–45). Now we are more concerned with audience than with the writer taking 'a risk by the inclusion of personal details that reveal the person behind the words' (NWREL). In other words, classroom teachers need more ways to teach voice than merely admonishing students to use their oral language."

About the Authors
SHERRY SEALE SWAIN is senior research associate in the Research and Evaluation Unit of the National Writing Project, working with researchers across the country to develop writing prompts and assessments. She has been a member of NCTE since 1987.

RICHARD L. GRAVES is professor emeritus of English Education at Auburn University and editor of several volumes on composition and teaching, including three editions of Rhetoric and Composition; Beyond the Cognitive Domain with Alice Brand; and Writing, Teaching, Learning. He has belonged to NCTE since 2000.

DAVID T. MORSE is interim head of Counseling and Educational Psychology at Mississippi State University, with research interests in applications of measurement and statistics principles, giftedness and creativity, and effectiveness of educational programs.


Swain, Sherry Seale, Richard L. Graves, and David T. Morse. "The Emerging Shape of Voice." English Journal 104.5 (2015) 30-36. Copyright ©2015 by the National Council of Teachers of English. Posted with Permission.

Download the Article

PDF Download "The Emerging Shape of Voice"

© 2019 National Writing Project